Which Is More Efficient A Fireplace Or Furnace?

As the winter progresses, it isn’t surprising that you’ll spend more time inside, working at home, or just avoiding the cold weather outdoors. You need a heat source that can keep your family warm without burning a hole through your pocket. Many homes are equipped with fireplaces and furnaces, both of which have impressive features and significant drawbacks. Most people ask if using a fireplace or a furnace is more efficient. This article compares fireplace vs furnace efficiency from a practical outlook.

Explore Our Heating System Services Call To Schedule A Free, In-Home Estimate

Fireplace Vs. Furnace: Which Is More Efficient?

image of a fireplace depicting fireplace vs furnace efficiency

Energy efficiency is one of the top selection criteria in heating systems. There are increasing energy prices in almost all countries. This is due to rising inflation and volatile supply. Therefore, you need a heating system that will keep you comfortable without paying a fortune. Otherwise, you may not be able to sustain heating in your home.

Moreover, high-efficiency systems have lower carbon emissions. If you care about your impact on the environment, focus on the system’s efficiency ratings. Some comparisons of systems provide a clear winner. On the other hand, others have a close gap, where any differences can be ignored. Consequently, you can select a source of heat using different factors.

Call Today: (410) 876-6800

Wood Fireplaces: Beautiful Yet Inefficient

image of a fireplace chimney and money depicting fireplace efficiency

Fireplaces are a classic. Firewood has been used by many homes for thousands of years. It is a simple and effective method for creating heat. All you need to do is chop wood, throw them in the fireplace, and light them. The smoke should escape via the chimney so that you can enjoy the warmth and light. The flames also have a hypnotizing effect that can leave you in a trance. A fireplace offers a warm ambiance when entertaining guests or lounging around on a cold winter night with some hot cocoa. However, you shouldn’t select a heating source based on aesthetics only.

Unfortunately, wood fireplaces are highly inefficient. Studies suggest that only 25% of the heat that a fireplace generates remains inside, while 75% escapes to the chimney with the smoke. The wasted heat can jump to 90% in some cases. Firewood can be costly, so spending a lot on something you get so little from is discouraging. If you are budget-conscious, you may want to search for more efficient solutions as there are better options available.

Another reason you should avoid using wood fireplaces is safety. Burning wood cannot be left unattended. If you go out for a quick errand or go to sleep, you need to extinguish the fire. If you don’t, an unfortunate event may happen, and you won’t be present to keep the fire from spreading. The risk of this happening is low but has huge consequences. Therefore, the possibility shouldn’t be ignored. You should also think about how fireplaces can impact your indoor air quality. Most of the smoke is released via the chimney, but some VOCs, carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, and ash may still circulate in your home.

Learn More About Our Heating System Services Call To Schedule An Appointment

Gas Fireplaces: Better But Still Lacking

image of a gas fireplace after a propane fireplace installation

If you want the perks of having a fireplace without the hassles, a gas fireplace may be what you want. You don’t have to burn wood and worry about particles mixing with indoor air. Moreover, you don’t have to worry much about safety. A gas-powered fireplace is a more convenient solution because it uses a steady fuel supply to keep the fire burning. It lacks the charm crackling wood has, but it offers higher efficiency and better heat conversion. Many consider this to be a welcome trade-off.

The Annual Fuel Efficiency ratio (AFUE) rating of a gas fireplace is around 70%. This is a massive difference from the wood fireplace’s efficiency of 10% to 25%. You receive great benefits when you change the fuel source. You get more value from your money, but this isn’t the best you can get. A gas furnace still offers more impressive efficiency, with 80% to 90% AFUE ratings depending on the unit. Furnaces give you better value, so consider it if you can get advanced equipment.

Note that a gas fireplace is still a fireplace. It can only heat the immediate area. It isn’t an issue if you only wish to warm a single room, like your living room during family gatherings. A fireplace may be enough to heat a small shed, studio, or cottage. However, it is not enough to sustain heating in a typical family home with several floors and rooms. It is best that you utilize a gas furnace as it offers whole-house heating.

Call To Make An Appointment

Furnace: The Best Option

The modern furnace offers versatility. Units come in different sizes, so you can match them to your unique heating needs. Furnaces use a network of ducts to push heated air into other areas around your home, ensuring whole-house heating. This heating system may not offer a visual spectacle, but you receive energy-efficient heating consistently during winter. You can go around your home comfortably, and your family can sleep soundly in their rooms.

A high-efficiency gas furnace may have as much as 98% efficiency. This will let you enjoy low fuel usage and affordable monthly costs, especially compared to other options. Therefore, you can keep the furnace on throughout winter if needed. You will have more fuel savings in the long run, making up for the high initial cost of installation. You will receive impressive returns from your investment.

Click Here To Call Tevis Energy



Practical homeowners aren’t all about the design. You should also think about efficiency when choosing between a furnace and a fireplace. It will affect your budget and carbon footprint. Comparing the efficiencies of these two heating systems will show you that gas furnaces beat fireplaces by far. Gas furnaces also provide better safety, convenience, and air quality. Hire a reputable HVAC technician to calculate the scientific load and install the furnace correctly. Having experienced professionals assist you will ensure you can enjoy safe and comfortable winters for years to come.

Tevis Energy’s sister company, Modern Comfort, performs HVAC installations, replacements, tune-ups, and more. Our technicians can provide you with expert HVAC services to ensure that your system provides you with the comfort and efficiency you deserve. Call now to schedule an appointment.

Get Started - Call Tevis Energy Today

Call Tevis Energy For All Your HVAC Needs

Tevis Energy Logo

Tevis Energy provides first-rate HVAC services in the area. Our team of professionally certified HVAC contractors can address all of your heating and cooling needs, such as furnace repairs, HVAC replacements, mini-split installations, and more. All our skilled, experienced, and knowledgeable techs can service your HVAC system accurately.

Need affordable and excellent HVAC service costs in the area? No worries. You are in excellent hands with Tevis Energy. Our tune-up services help improve your energy efficiency, indoor air quality, and comfort while lowering your energy expenditures. If you need HVAC replacements or repairs, we can recommend the most suitable solutions for your home and budget. Our work is guaranteed because your satisfaction is important to us. Book a service appointment with Tevis Energy and call us today. We provide free, in-home estimates.

Call Now: (410) 876-6800

You can click here to contact us now or call us at (410) 876-6800 to find out more! Click the link to view our service area.

Posted in