When To Repair Vs. Replace Your Heating System

You can depend on your heating system during winter. Regardless of the low temperature outside, it can keep your home warm. However, problems may develop as time passes. Eventually, as the system ages, its performance will decline, and you will be forced to decide between a heating system repair vs replace.

It isn’t always easy to determine which type of heating service you should opt for. Most homeowners attempt to get furnace repairs repeatedly due to the lower cost. However, some cases warrant a heating system replacement as the more logical and economical choice.

Explore Our Heating System Services Call To Schedule A Free, In-Home Estimate

When To Choose A Heating System Repair Vs. Replacement

image of an hvac tech fixing a gas furnace

Read on to learn several obvious signs that suggest you should get a heating system replacement. Knowing these signs means you can save money on repairs and have a comfortable and energy-efficient home.

Call Today: (410) 876-6800

Age Of Your Heating System

Heating systems are generally built to be dependable. They can last for 15 to 30 years, depending on factors like upkeep, manufacturer, design, and usage frequency. You can attempt to maximize these 30 years, but it isn’t always possible. There may be times when issues begin developing as early as 12 to 15 years. You may have already had your equipment serviced many times before, so it isn’t as painful to retire it. You will save yourself from the hassle repairs can bring when you get a replacement. Technological advancements also make newer models more appealing.

Related Article: Signs Your Heat Exchanger May Be Cracked On Your Gas Furnace

Increased Home Heating Costs

image of a couple calculating home heating costs at home

An increase in fuel use means there is also an increase in energy costs. The cost of fuel may vary over time and can rise because of high demand and shortages. However, having an old or underperforming heating unit means it will consume more fuel than it typically does. The extra amount of money to be used to buy fuel can add to a significant sum. Some repairs may help improve efficiency but not by a lot. Replacing your heating system with a new one means you can immediately enjoy low fuel usage and operating cost in your home.

Learn More About Our Heating System Services Call To Schedule An Appointment

Related Article: Variable-Speed Furnaces Can Improve Home Efficiency

Reduced Energy Efficiency

Every machine goes through a gradual reduction in efficiency as time passes. You can slow this reduction down with methods such as regular maintenance. However, decreasing efficiency cannot be removed completely.

The heating system consumes more fuel to generate the same amount of heat as its efficiency decreases. There will come a time when the reduced efficiency can be so extreme that there is excessive fuel consumption.

If this is the case, replacing the heater is more logical than holding on to your old system. High energy use negatively impacts the environment as it releases more greenhouse gasses into the atmosphere. You will also have a significant increase in your heating bills.

Related Article: What Are 3 Ways You Can Tell If Your Heater Is Energy Efficient?

Frequent Repairs On Your Heating System

image of an old gas furnace that requires a furnace repair

A homeowner can get their system repaired repeatedly as long as qualified technicians and available parts are available. Therefore, it is possible to achieve a 30-year service life. However, few homeowners reach this mark as repairs can be costly in both money and time. Yearly visits from professional technicians may be tolerable. However, it may not be worth it when they have to visit you three or more times a year. You may want to consider channeling all the heater repair costs into a new furnace instead so you get better reliability.

Call To Make An Appointment

Heat Imbalance and Discomfort Around Your Home

The heating system’s effectiveness also reduces over time. Your heating system may have been able to keep all rooms warm to keep your family comfortable during its first few years. However, you may notice that the rooms farther from the system feel colder until you can’t stay inside because they are too cold.

This is an obvious sign that you need to replace your heating system. The unit cannot do its task properly anymore, so you need to install a heater that can provide you with your heating needs properly. Do this as soon as you can.

Related Article: Why Are My Rooms Heating Unevenly?

Poor Indoor Air Quality

We usually worry about the quality of the air outside because of pollutants from cars and factories, among others. Many do not realize that this can also lead to poor indoor air quality. Dirt, dust, and debris can get trapped inside your home and be distributed throughout your home with the indoor air, resulting in discomfort among the home’s occupants. You can improve indoor air with regular air filter replacements, duct cleaning, and strategically placing and installing UV lights. You can also use an air purifier. If these methods are already in place, but there is no improvement in the air quality, consider getting a whole system replacement.



There is endless debate on whether to get a repair or replacement. You need to be proactive at some point to protect your family’s health and to achieve long-term financial stability. You can try going for low-cost solutions first to see if they work. If you act immediately, the problems may be resolved quickly without costing too much. However, you should be open that you might need to get a complete heating system replacement once your unit has aged or it displays some of the other signs listed in this article.

Tevis Energy’s sister company, Modern Comfort, performs HVAC installations, replacements, tune-ups, and more. Our technicians can provide you with expert HVAC services to ensure that your system provides you with the comfort and efficiency you deserve. Call now to schedule an appointment.

Click Here To Call Tevis Energy

Call Tevis Energy For All Of Your Heating Needs

Tevis Energy Logo
Need top-notch heating and cooling services in the area? No worries. Tevis Energy can provide superior HVAC replacements, repairs, maintenance, and installations. All our professionally certified technicians have the proper tools, years of experience, and extensive knowledge to service any HVAC system correctly and on time.

Tevis Energy guarantees to have highly affordable furnace replacement or repair costs. If you need to replace your system, we can recommend the most suitable one for your home and budget. We always prioritize your energy efficiency, comfort, indoor air quality, and more. Call Tevis Energy today to book an appointment. We provide free, in-home estimates.

Call Now: (410) 876-6800

You can click here to contact us now or call us at (410) 876-6800 to find out more! Click the link to view our service area.

Posted in